PAT AND DICK AND CHIANG AND MAO: The First ‘CNN Opera’ Finally Appears on Met Gala
The Metropolitan Opera’s Nixon in China rides on powerful performances and a meticulous, lavishly outfitted production. Through the miracle of HD, I was able to see the February 12thperformance live at the AMC Town Center multiplex, along with a sizable handful of other opera buffs. John Adams, the work’s composer, conducted the production, and of course he brings authority to his score though he is not really what you’d call a master conductor. The Met Orchestra played magnificently, reproduced so vividly that the experience was the next best thing to being right there onstage with the singers.
Based on President Nixon’s 1972 visit to China and his meeting with Chairman Mao, Chou En-lai and others, the 1987 opera was transformative in several ways: It made us rethink what is potential fodder for opera, and it pioneered an innovative hyper-minimalist vocal style. But more than anything, its shimmering, brilliantly hued score – complete with a dense orchestral part that has influenced numerous composers since – makes it sheer fun to see and hear. And with China ever on the ascendancy, the opera has if anything even more pertinence today than it did in 1987.
This production will be of special interest to Kansas City audiences because two of the leads – James Maddalena (Nixon) and Richard Paul Fink (Henry Kissinger) – are to be a part of the Lyric Opera of Kansas City’s performances of the opera in the new Kauffman Center next season. Maddalena, who created the role at Houston Grand Opera, has become its definitive exponent: Despite diminishing vocal heft, he performed with incredible conviction, keeping the part compelling for the opera’s entire 3 ½-hour length. He has internalized this role as completely as any singer in any contemporary opera I know of. Robert Brubaker played the aging Mao Tse-tung (as his name was transliterated into English in the 1980s) with a mixture of frailty and inner strength that captured this man’s great complexity. Russell Braun’s Chou En-lai was a tortured, pensive man, dying of pancreatic cancer yet honored to be a part of such a historical moment; Braun’s is a deliciously rich and burnished baritone that I’d love to hear much more of. Richard Paul Fink was unsettlingly funny as Kissinger.
The sound and HD image were impeccable, though I found myself wishing for more medium and long shots and fewer extreme close-ups. (More than once, the camera was on a singer’s face when plenty else was going on.) Peter Sellars, one of the original creators of Nixon at Houston Grand Opera, directed the production with brilliant clarity. (He also directed the telecast.) I could have used more movement in some solo scenes, though, such as Pat Nixon’s big dramatic solo in Act 2: True, the stasis allowed us to focus purely on Janis Kelly’s splendid singing, but the end effect was textbook “park and bark.” And speaking of the women, Kathleen Kim was downright scary in the coloratura role of Madame Mao, Chiang Ch’ing, her hoydenish cries sending a shiver down my spine. (And as Kathleen herself pointed out in one of several backstage intermission interviews – elegantly hosted by Thomas Hampson – the real Madame Mao was just as intimidating in the documentary footage we have of her.)
Mark Morris’ dances, created for the 1987 original, were mellifluous when needed and powerfully dramatic in the Act 2 opera-within-an-opera. This opera scene, an emotional climax of uncommon emotional force, shows the Nixons demonstrating particular compassion for the downtrodden peasant girl of the story: With Morris’ wildly fresh and elaborate choreography providing the core of the movement, it is easily one of the most powerful scenes in contemporary opera.
Adrianne Lobel’s sets feature the famous Air Force One of Act 1 and a series of moveable chairs, cabinets, beds and animals. Everything about the look of the production – right down to Pat Nixon’s perfectly tailored red jacket with its double-row of buttons – was top-of-the line. (Costume designs are by Dunya Ramicova.) That’s what we’ve come to expect of the Met, and this time they delivered.
The Met’s Nixon in China will be encored in movie theaters around the Kansas City metro on March 2nd. See www.metoperafamily.org for more information, including the latest about upcoming HD telecasts.
To reach Paul Horsley, performing arts editor, send email to firstname.lastname@example.org.
Suddenly, classical radio is back. Almost exactly 20 years after its disappearance from the FM dial, the music that Kansas City is becoming known for worldwide has made its way…
Artists have always delighted in playing notes that are not in the scale, or painting outside the lines, or staging plays is odd places. After a few weeks of hand-wringing,…
Choirs always seem to bring joy into a room. And if the singers are feeling it, chances are it will spread to the listeners. “You dispel any myths or any…
When oboist Kristina Fulton spends hundreds of hours carving Mediterranean cane into paper-thin strips of reed, she has a single purpose in mind: to produce the most gorgeous sound possible.…